Getting Published: Like Waiting for Godot by Nannette Croce
The way some new writers approach getting published reminds me of the Samuel Beckett play Waiting for Godot. They insist on submitting to only the top-tier journals and end up waiting and waiting and waiting and never seeing their work in print.
New writers are aware, or at least they should be, when submitting to the "prestige" journals, that competition is fierce. You'll be up against the John Updikes and Alice Walkers who have learned a thing or two in their lifetimes including how to write damn good prose and poetry. You'll also be up against new writers who've graduated from the Iowa Writer's Workshop or attended Breadloaf or had one of those well-known writers as an instructor. However, you might also assume that, outside of these obvious advantages, the playing field remains fairly level. That is, editors read submissions as they come in and choose the best work to publish. All things being equal, sure, Annie Proulx wins out over Sally Unknown, but if Sally Unkown's piece arrives first, and it's really, really good, she has a pretty good chance of making it in.
Recently I had the opportunity to learn about a certain top-tier journal's acceptance process—which I think it's fair to assume is pretty representative. Call me naive, but, frankly, I was a little surprised at how tilted the playing field actually is. The process comprises three levels of readers and a piece can be rejected or advanced anywhere along the line. However, if the submission has an extra something going for it, say the writer has published with that journal before, or has a few prestigious credits, or is recommended by a known writer, etc., etc., that submission skips the slush pile and goes directly to the second level of readers. That may not sound like such a big advantage, but consider that, while that huge slush pile (because the pile of unknowns is always bigger than the pile of knowns) is being slogged through, the slots for the next issue are filling up.
I'm often surprised to learn how many writers still feel these elusive top tier credits are the only ones that really count. They're willing to go years and years writing for no one, rather than lowering their sights. That's not saying new writers should submit to publications that accept anything—though if simply having your work read is the goal, there's nothing wrong with that. However, there are many, many publications between the level of we-print-anything-we-get and the top tier, and many of those are online.
I can attest for the fact that The Rose & Thorn is selective. On the other hand, unlike the journal I describe above, we read and accept work as it arrives, and while credits are nice to know, they hold very little value in the selection process. In fact I myself have rejected many pieces by writers with a string of excellent print credits because the piece just wasn't a good fit for us.
Publishing online has several added advantages over print. Unless you can beat even longer odds and have your piece chosen for one of the award anthologies such as Pushcart or O. Henry or Best American, your work is likely to be read once and forgotten. It may live on in back issues, but how many people buy those? Online publications usually archive work, sometimes for several years, where it can be read and commented on with just a click of the mouse. (One of my pieces was re-discovered three years after the original publication and was linked to a someone's blog.) Also, by their very nature, online publications reach a wider audience. The Rose & Thorn is read by English speakers all over the world.
If you still prefer print, there are a number of mid-level and regional publications where new or emerging writers face less competition as well. Bottom line is good writers can get published but not necessarily in the top tier. So, if that's what you hold out for, you may end up "waiting for Godot."
Nannette Croce is Co-Managing Editor of The Rose & Thorn. Her short story The Box of Cereal recently appeared in the Winter '07 issue of The Rose & Thorn. Another of her short stories, The Foundations of Churchill, will appear in the inaugural issue of Sotto Voce this fall.
